| YEAR | ANGLERS | LAKE |
| 1989 | RAY SCULLY | CROSS RIVER |
| 1990 | RAY SCULLY | CROSS RIVER |
| 1991 | RAY SCULLY | OSCAWANA |
| 1992 | RAY SCULLY | WHALEY |
| 1993 | STEVE BUREY | MAHOPAC |
| 1994 | RAY SCULLY | CANDLEWOOD |
| 1995 | IRA FRIEDLAND | CANDLEWOOD |
| 1996 | GREG KEEGAN & MIKE NICOLETTI | EAST TWIN |
| 1997 | JOE PETROZZA & KEVIN CUNNINGHAM | EAST TWIN |
| 1998 | RAY SCULLY & DENNIS SCULLY | EAST TWIN |
| 1999 | MIKE FRIEDLAND & HOLLIS GRIFFITH | CANDLEWOOD |
| 2000 | RAY SCULLY & SEAN KELLY SR. | CONN. RIVER |
| 2001 | MARK WATKINS & DAVE MC LAUGHLIN | CONN. RIVER |
| 2002 | DOM LAMANNO & DON HELLER |
SUSQUEHANA |
| 2003 | RAY SCULLY & GREG KEEGAN | CANDY/LILLY |
| 2004 | JOHN REILLY & JOHN TSAOUSIS | CANDLEWOOD |
| 2005 | KEVIN CUNNINGHAM & PAUL RITCHIE | CANDLEWOOD |
| 2006 | SCOTT GARRISON & DAVE MC LAUGHLIN | CANDLEWOOD |
| 2007 | SCOTT GARRISON & DAVE MC LAUGHLIN | CANDLEWOOD |
| 2008 | BRENDAN CUCINELLO & JOE CONTRINO | CANDLEWOOD |
| 2009 | RICH TOMASINI & BOB TOMASINI | CANDLEWOOD |
| 2010 | SEAN KELLY JR. & PAT XIQUES (G) | CANDLEWOOD |