| YEAR | ANGLERS | LAKE |
| 1999 | BRIAN RODRIGUEZ & DAVE MC LAUGHLIN | CONGAMOND |
| 2000 | KEVIN CUNNINGHAM & PAUL RITCHIE | HUDSON |
| 2001 | PAUL RITCHIE & DON HELLER | HUDSON |
| 2001 | BOB CASELLA & MARK WATKINS | HUDSON |
| 2002 | GEORGE PEPE & JOE PEPE | COPAKE LAKE |
| 2003 | RAY SCULLY & GREG KEEGAN | OSCAWANA |
| 2004 | JOE PIDO & DANNY COBOTIC | MOHAWK |
| 2005 | RAY SCULLY & PAUL RITCHIE | SARATOGA |
| 2006 | PAUL RITCHIE & KEVIN CUNNINGHAM | CHAMPLAIN |
| 2007 | NEIL DE STEFANO & GEORGE PEPE | BOMOSEENE |
| 2008 | BILL SLAVIS & DAVE MC LAUGHLIN | LILINONAH |
| 2009 | NEIL DE STEFANO & MIKE DE PALMA | COPAKE |